Hunton Insurance Recovery Blog

Wildfires continue to present serious risks for California property owners. Unfortunately, commercial property owners, corporate facilities, landlords, and homeowners need to overcome not only the flames themselves, but also remediating hazardous contamination against a backdrop of unpredictable and ambiguous environmental safety standards. In response to the destructive Los Angeles area fires in 2025, the California Legislature recently introduced Assembly Bill 1642 aimed at creating uniform science-based standards for evaluating, testing, and clearing wildfire-impacted properties.

While millions have been captivated by Wayfarer Studio’s production of “It Ends With Us,” a lesser-known but real-life insurance drama is unfolding off-screen. Last week, Harco National Insurance Company found itself in the spotlight when it filed a declaratory judgment action against its insureds, including, among others, Wayfarer Studios LLC, It Ends With Us Movie LLC and Justin Baldoni (jointly “Defendants”) asserting it has no obligation to defend the claims brought against Defendants by Blake Lively in Lively v. Wayfarer Studios, et al., U.S.D.C., S.D.N.Y. Case No. 1:24-cv-10049-LJL (the “Underlying Action”). 

The recent California federal court decision Scottsdale Ins. Co. v. Beachcomber Mgmt. Crystal Cove, LLC, et al. illustrates the perils that corporate policyholders may face in obtaining the full benefit of the bargain when they procure new D&O insurance after making a claim under a prior policy.  2025 WL 257599, at *13 (C.D. Cal. Jan. 21, 2025).  In Scottsdale, the court agreed that an insurer who sold a D&O policy could deny coverage for a lawsuit filed against two corporate executives during its policy period because that lawsuit involved some of the same allegations of wrongdoing as did a claim the policyholder previously submitted to a former D&O insurer.  The new policy contained a very broadly worded “prior notice exclusion” that barred coverage for all claims “in any way involving” any wrongful conduct, facts, circumstances, or situations as to which notice had been given to a prior D&O insurer.  

Recent business disruptions have highlighted  the vulnerabilities retailers face when unexpected events force closures.  Whether it’s a utility outage disrupting operations or a fire at a supplier’s facility or neighboring property cutting into sales, insurance may help cover business interruption losses.