Hunton Insurance Recovery Blog

Examinations under oath (EUOs) are a common coverage condition in property and other first-party insurance policies that can make or break an insurance claim.  In theory, EUOs are straightforward:  they’re an investigative tool for insurers to gather information about a claim.[1]  But in practice, insurers often use them to poke holes in the policyholder’s story, identify grounds to challenge coverage, and even set up fraud claims. 

The Supreme Court of Virginia’s decision yesterday finding no coverage for fire damage to a building is a cautionary tale for companies acquiring other companies. Erie Ins. Exch. v. EPC MD 15, LLC, 2019 WL 238168 (Va. Jan. 17, 2019). In that case, Erie Insurance issued a property insurance policy to EPC. The policy covered EPC only and did not cover any subsidiaries of EPC. EPC then acquired the sole member interest in Cyrus Square, LLC.  Following the acquisition, fire damaged a building that Cyrus Square owned.