Fifth Circuit to Decide Whether Indemnification Claim for Credit Card Fines Is Covered Under Specialty Retailer’s D&O and Corporate Liability Insurance Policy
Time 1 Minute Read

An insured seeking coverage for credit card fees assessed against its third-party payment processor following a data breach recently filed an appeal in the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals. Spec’s, a liquor store chain with over 160 locations throughout Texas, suffered two major data breaches of its credit card payment system, resulting in the loss of customer information and credit card numbers. Spec’s accepts Visa and MasterCard payments from its customers through a third-party processor, First Data. As a result of the breach, First Data incurred liability assessments from MasterCard and Visa totaling $9.6 million. A merchant agreement required Spec’s to indemnify First Data for any assessments First Data incurred as a result of a breach of Spec’s system. First Data demanded indemnification from Spec’s for the fees. Without any adjudication of First Data’s claims and without Spec’s consent, First Data allegedly wrongfully withheld $4.2 million in credit card payments owed to Spec’s. Consequently, Spec’s sued First Data in Tennessee federal court to recover the $4.2 million.

Read the full alert.

You May Also Be Interested In

Time 2 Minute Read

The New York Office of the Attorney General recently reached a $500,000 settlement with a New York orthopedics practice for allegedly failing to protect patient and employee information in light of a 2023 data breach.

Time 2 Minute Read

On December 16, 2025, the Federal Trade Commission announced an enforcement action against Illusory Systems Inc., a Utah-based company doing business as Nomad, following a major data breach in which hackers stole $186 million from consumers.

Time 2 Minute Read

Nishith Desai Associates reports that on November 13, 2025, India’s Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology enacted India’s Digital Personal Data Protection Rules, 2025, which operationalize India’s Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023.

Time 7 Minute Read

A prominent cryptocurrency exchange’s recent announcement that it had reincorporated from Delaware to Texas has created a buzz among publicly traded digital asset businesses. The move follows an invitation from Texas Governor Greg Abbott to come to “Y’all Street” and a series of recent legislative developments in Texas to modernize the Texas Business Organizations Code (TBOC) to make Texas more attractive as a place to incorporate. In this article we summarize some changes in the laws governing Texas business entities resulting from the recently completed session of the Texas Legislature.

Search

Subscribe Arrow

Recent Posts

Categories

Tags

Authors

Archives

Jump to Page