Notwithstanding the FDA’s finding that “[c]urrent scientific evidence does not demonstrate that levels of microplastics or nanoplastics detected in foods pose a risk to human health,” the plaintiffs’ bar steadfastly continues to file class action lawsuits claiming otherwise. Even worse, many of the plaintiffs in those cases have boldly failed even to test the products at issue in the lawsuit, relying instead on generalized assertions in microplastic “studies” that have no bearing on the actual products in question. Fortunately, recent decisions have viewed such claims with scrutiny, dismissing them where the plaintiffs have failed to allege: (1) the levels at which microplastics become unsafe; and (2) the level of microplastics in the defendant’s products.
For example, in Miller, et al. v. Handi-Craft Company, Inc., the plaintiffs claimed the defendant’s baby bottles and sippy cups contained polypropylene, that “studies” showed polypropylene leached microplastics when heated, that exposure to such microplastics correlated with adverse health effects, and that the defendant failed to disclose the alleged risk of such health effects.1 Notably, the “studies” upon which the plaintiffs relied did not even reference the defendant’s products.
Dismissing the claims, the court held that the plaintiffs must allege “(1) the levels at which [microplastics] are unsafe, and that (2) the defendant’s product contains those unsafe levels.” The plaintiff’s vague assertions that the products released “copious amounts of microplastics” did not suffice. The court went on to reject nearly every other critical element of the case, such as the assertion that the defect is related to the product’s central function, as well as the defendant’s alleged knowledge of any supposed risks.
Similarly, in Daly v. The Wonderful Company, the plaintiffs claimed the defendant falsely advertised bottled water as “natural artesian water,” even though it allegedly contained microplastics.2 The plaintiffs relied on two “studies” that claimed 93% of tested brands of bottled water (not including the defendant’s product) contained microplastics, that stress on the bottle cap and neck caused the contamination, and that microplastics were toxic to marine invertebrates. Because the plaintiffs did not test the actual product in question, the court dismissed the claims with leave to amend.
The Daly plaintiffs’ amended allegations fared no better. Attempting to cure the deficiencies cited by the court in its prior dismissal order, the plaintiffs claimed that their attorney performed an investigation of the product, and that they had retained an expert who would perform further analysis. As to the alleged testing by counsel, the court found the allegation “hard to take seriously” as the plaintiffs included “no information about what sort of testing was done, under what conditions, or what its results were (aside from the generalized statement that Fiji Water ‘contained microplastics’).” Furthermore, the plaintiffs claimed the testing constituted work product that they would not disclose in any event. As to the alleged future testing, the court found that the plaintiff’s “intention to have an expert do more testing in the future does not advance his claims over the plausibility line.” The court noted that “the key facts are currently available to the plaintiff,” and so the court expects them to adequately plead those facts.
As microplastics litigation expands, courts should continue to hold plaintiffs to the minimal burden of actually testing the product(s) in question before filing suit. Assumptions of plastic levels and related toxicity and generalized “studies” of common plastics should not open the doors to class action litigation.
1 No. 4:24-cv-03782 (C.D. Cal.)
2 No. 1:24-cv-01267 (N.D. Ill.)
- Associate
Gray focuses his practice on product liability, toxic tort, and general commercial litigation. Prior to joining the firm, Gray clerked for The Honorable John Cagle of the Alaska Superior Court. During law school, he served as a ...
Search
Recent Posts
Categories
- Advertising & Marketing
- Bankruptcy
- Class Action
- Competition/Antitrust
- Consumer Protection
- Corporate Governance
- Environmental
- General
- Health Care
- Insurance
- IP
- Labor and Employment
- Mergers & Acquisitions
- Patent Infringement
- Patents
- Privacy & Cybersecurity
- Product Liability
- Real Estate
- Regulatory
- Regulatory
- Technology & E-Commerce
Tags
- 29 C.F.R. § 785.48
- 396-r
- 3D Printer
- 3D Printing
- A. Todd Brown
- A.S. Research (ASR)
- Aaron P. Simpson
- Accountability
- Administrative Exemption
- Advertisers
- Advertising
- Advertising Claims
- Advertising Guidelines
- Advertising Idea
- Agency Guidance
- Agency Principles
- AI
- AI Interviewing Platforms
- AI Technology Reviews
- Algorithmic Accountability Act
- Align
- Americans with Disabilities Act
- Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA)
- Andrea DeField
- Ann Marie Buerkle
- Annual Reports
- anti-aging
- Anti-Discrimination
- APEX Agreement
- Arbitration
- Arbitration Agreements
- Arizona
- Arkansas
- Arthritis
- Artificial Intelligence
- Artificial Intelligence (AI)
- Asbestos
- Assembly Bill 51 (AB 51)
- ATDS
- Australia
- Auto-renewals
- Automatic Telephone Dialing System (ATDS)
- Automobile
- Automotive Body Parts Association (ABPA)
- Back to Work Emergency Ordinance
- biased endorsements
- Biden Administration
- Biometric Data
- Biometric Information
- Biometric Information Privacy Act (BIPA)
- BIPA
- Bitcoin
- Blockchain
- Board Diversity Disclosure
- Boards of Directors
- Bonuses
- Braille
- Branding
- Breach
- Breach of Contract
- Business Interruption
- Business Interruption Loss
- Businessowner’s Insurance
- California
- California Assembly Bill 2011
- California Employment Laws
- California Fair Employment and Housing Act
- California False Claims Act
- California Labor Code
- California Senate Bill 6
- California’s Unfair Competition Law
- CAMS
- Canada
- Cannabis
- CBD
- CBP
- CCPA
- Celebrity Endorsers
- Center for Disease Control (CDC)
- CFIUS
- CGL
- Chatbot
- Children’s Advertising
- Children’s Advertising Review Unit
- Children’s Online Privacy Protection Act (COPPA)
- China
- Christopher J. Dufek
- Christopher W. Hasbrouck
- Christy Kiely
- Class Action
- Class Action Litigation
- Class Actions
- Clawback
- Click-to-Cancel
- Climate Change
- clinical trials
- Collective Action
- Colorado
- Commercial General Liability
- Commercial Leasing
- Commercial Messaging
- Commercial Products
- Commodity Futures Trading Commission
- Compliance
- Confidentiality
- Congress
- Connecticut
- Consent
- Consent Order
- Consumer Advertising
- Consumer Data
- Consumer Financial Protection Bureau
- Consumer Fraud
- consumer loyalty program
- Consumer Product Safety Act
- Consumer Products
- Consumer Products Safety Commission (CPSC)
- Consumer Protection
- Consumer Review Fairness Act of 2016 (CRFA)
- Consumer Reviews
- Consumer Rights
- Contamination
- Contract Law
- Controlled Substance Act
- Cookies
- Cookware
- COPPA
- Copyright
- Coronavirus/COVID-19
- Corp Fin
- Corporate Governance
- Corporate Reporting
- Corporate Sustainability
- Corporate Transparency Act (CTA)
- Costco
- Counterfeit Goods
- Counterfeit Goods Seizure Act of 2019
- CPPA
- CPRA
- CPSA
- CPSC
- Crack House Statute
- CRFA
- Crypto
- Cryptocurrency
- CSPA
- Cuba
- Currency
- Customs and Border Protection
- Cyber
- Cyber Coverage
- D&O
- D&O policies
- D. Andrew Quigley
- Damages
- Data Breach
- Davidson
- Deceptive Advertising
- DEI
- Delaware
- DEP
- Department of Justice
- Department of Labor
- Development Impact Fee
- Digital Assets
- digital currency
- Disclosures
- Distribution
- Division of Corporation Finance
- Dodd-Frank
- DOJ
- DOL
- Duty to Defend
- Duty to Indemnify
- e-liquid products
- Eddie Bauer
- EEOC
- Electric Vehicles
- Eleventh Circuit
- Emily Burkhardt Vicente
- Employee Rights
- Endorsement
- Endorsement Guides
- Endorsement Notice
- Endorsements
- endorser monitoring requirements
- Enforcement
- Environmental Impact
- Environmental Protection Agency
- Environmental Protection Agency (EPA)
- EPA
- Epidemic
- ESG
- ESG Disclosure
- EU Regulation
- European Union
- European Unitary Patent
- EV Charging
- Exceptions
- Exclusions
- Executive Order
- Executive Orders
- Exercise Machines
- Extended Producer Responsibility (EPR)
- FAA
- Fair Labor Standards Act
- Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA)
- fair use
- False Advertising
- False Advertising Claims
- False Advertising Law
- False Claims Act
- Family Leave Policies
- FAR
- FCC
- FCRA
- FDA
- Federal Acquisition Regulations
- Federal Arbitration Act (FAA)
- Federal Communications Commission
- Federal Contractors
- Federal Contracts
- Federal District Court
- Federal Government Contractor
- Federal Trade Commission
- Federal Trade Commission (FTC)
- FFDCA
- FIFRA
- Fifth Circuit
- Final Rule
- Financial Technology
- FinCEN
- FinHub
- Fireworks
- First Amendment
- Fixing America’s Surface Transportation (FAST) Act
- Florida
- Florida House of Representatives (HB 963) and Florida Senate (SB 1670)
- Florida Legislature
- FLSA
- FLSA/Wage & Hour
- food delivery
- Food Safety
- Form 10-K
- Formaldehyde Standards for Composite Wood Products Act of 2010
- fractional interests
- Franchise
- Frederic Chang
- Free Trials
- FTC
- FTC Act
- Gavin Newsom
- GDPR
- General Liability
- Geoffrey B. Fehling
- Georgia
- Gift Cards
- GoodRx
- Gramm-Leach-Bliley (GLB) Act
- Green
- Green Guides
- Greenhouse Gas
- Gun Safety
- Hart-Scott-Rodino
- Hart-Scott-Rodino (HSR)
- Hashtag
- Hawaii
- Health Care
- Health Claims
- Hedge Fund
- HIPAA
- hoverboards
- human capital
- Human Rights
- Illinois
- Illinois Artificial Intelligence Video Interview Act (the Illinois Act)
- Illinois Biometric Information Privacy Act (BIPA)
- Indiana
- Indoor Mall
- Influencer Marketing
- Infringement
- initial public offerings (IPOs)
- Injury
- Insurance
- Insurance Loss
- Insurance Provider
- Intellectual Property
- Intellectual Property Licenses in Bankruptcy Act
- Interest Rate
- International
- International Trade Commission
- International Trade Commission (ITC)
- Internet
- Inventorship
- investigation
- INVISALIGN
- Iowa
- IP
- Ireland
- IT
- ITC
- iTERO
- Junk Fees
- Katherine Miller
- Kurt A. Powell
- Kurt G. Larkin
- Labeling
- Labeling Rules
- Labor
- Labor Code Private Attorneys General Act of 2004 (PAGA)
- Labor Organizing
- Labor Unions
- Land Use
- Landlord
- Latin America
- Lautenberg Act
- Lawsuit Reform Alliance of New York (LRANY)
- Lead
- Lease
- Legislation
- Leveraged Loans
- Liability Insurance Policy
- Liberty Insurance Corporation
- Liberty Mutual Fire Insurance Company
- LIBOR Discontinuation
- liquidity
- Litigation
- Live Chat
- Lost Profits
- Lost Sales
- Louisiana
- M&A
- Made in the USA
- Made in USA
- MagicSleeve
- Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act
- Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act (MMWA)
- Maine
- Malcolm C. Weiss
- Manufacturing
- Marketing Claims
- Maryland
- Massachusetts
- Matthew T. McLellan
- Maya M. Eckstein
- MD&A
- Medtail
- Membership cancellation
- Metaverse
- MeToo Movement
- Mexico
- Michael J. Mueller
- Michael S. Levine
- microplastics
- Microplastics Litigation
- Minimum Wage
- Minnesota
- Minnesota Pollution Control Agency (MPCA)
- Misclassification
- Mislabeling
- Mission Product Holdings
- Missouri
- Mobile
- Mobile App
- Multi-Family Housing Development
- Multi-Level Marketing Program (MLM)
- NAA
- NAD
- NASA
- Nasdaq
- National Advertising Division
- National Advertising Division (NAD)
- National Advertising Review Board
- National Labor Relations Act
- National Labor Relations Board
- National Products Inc.
- National Retail Federation
- Natural Disaster
- Nebraska
- Negligence Claims
- Neil K. Gilman
- Network Outage
- Nevada
- New Jersey
- New York
- NHTSA
- NIL rights
- Ninth Circuit
- NLRA
- NLRB
- no-action request
- Non-Compete
- Non-Exempt
- non-fungible token (NFT)
- North Carolina
- Nutrition Labels
- Obama Administration
- Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA)
- Occurrence
- Office of Labor Standards Enforcement
- Ohio
- Oklahoma
- Online Cash Providers
- Online Retailer
- Online Reviews
- Opioids
- Oregon
- Overboarding
- Overtime
- Overtime Exemptions
- Ownership
- Packaging
- PAGA
- Pandemic
- Patent
- Patent Infringement
- Patents
- Paul T. Moura
- Pay Ratio
- Pay-To-Play Rankings
- Penalty
- Pennsylvania
- Personal and Advertising Injury
- Personal Data
- Personal Information
- Personally Identifiable Information
- Pesticides
- PFAS
- Physical Loss or Damage
- Policy
- price gouging
- Primary and Umbrella Policies
- Privacy
- Privacy Guidelines
- Privacy Policy
- Privacy Protections
- Procurement
- Product Liability
- Product Packaging
- Prohibition on Sale
- Property Insurance
- Property Rights
- Proposed Legislation
- Proposition 65
- Proxy Access
- proxy materials
- Proxy Statements
- Public Companies
- Purdue Pharma
- Randall S. Parks
- Ransomware
- Real Estate
- Recall
- Recalls
- Recording
- Regulation
- Regulation S-K
- Restaurants
- Restrictive Covenants
- Retail
- Retail Developers
- Retail Development
- Retail Industry Leaders Association
- Retail Litigation Center
- Rounding
- Rulemaking
- Ryan A. Glasgow
- Sales Tax
- Salesforce
- SD8 coins
- SEC
- SEC Disclosure
- Second Circuit
- Section 337
- Section 365
- Secure and Fair Enforcement Banking Act of 2019 (“SAFE Banking Act”)
- Securities
- Securities and Exchange Commission
- Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC)
- security checks
- Senate
- Senate Data Handling Report
- Sergio F. Oehninger
- Service Contract Act (SCA)
- Service Interruption
- Service Provider
- SHARE
- Shareholder
- Shareholder Proposals
- Sign-In Wrap Agreement
- Slogan
- Smart Contracts
- Social Media
- Social Media Influencers
- Software
- South Carolina
- South Dakota
- Special purpose acquisition companies (SPACs)
- Sponsors and Gifting
- Sponsorship
- State Attorneys General
- State Legislation
- Store Closures
- Subscription Services
- Substantiation
- Substantiation Notice
- Supplier
- Supply Chain
- Supply contracts
- Supreme Court
- Sustainability
- Syed S. Ahmad
- Synovia
- Targeted Advertising
- Tax
- TCCWNA
- TCPA
- Technology
- Technology Innovation
- Telemarketing
- Telephone Consumer Protection Act
- Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA)
- Tempnology LLC
- Tenant
- Tennessee
- Terms and Conditions
- Texas
- The Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA)
- Third-Party
- Thomas R. Waskom
- Title VII
- Tokenization
- Tokens
- Toxic Chemicals
- Toxic Substances Control Act
- Toxic Substances Control Act (TSCA)
- Trade Dress
- Trademark
- Trademark Infringement
- Trademark Trial and Appeal Board (TTAB)
- TransUnion
- Travel
- Trump Administration
- TSCA
- TSCA Title VI
- U.S. Department of Justice
- U.S. Department of Labor
- U.S. Food and Drug Administration
- U.S. House of Representatives
- U.S. Patent and Trademark Office
- Umbrella Liability
- Unfair and Deceptive Use
- Union
- Union Organizing
- United Specialty Insurance Company
- Unmanned Aircraft
- Unruh Civil Rights Act
- UPSTO
- US Chamber of Commerce
- US Customs and Border Protection (CBP)
- US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA)
- US International Trade Commission (ITC)
- US Origin Claims
- US Patent and Trademark Office
- US Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO)
- US Supreme Court
- USDA
- USPTO
- Utah
- Varidesk
- Vendor
- Vermont
- Virginia
- Volatile Organic Compound (VOC) Emissions
- W. Jeffery Edwards
- Wage and Hour
- Walter J. Andrews
- Warranties
- Warranty
- Washington
- Washington DC
- WCAG
- Web Accessibility
- Website
- Website Accessibility
- Weight Loss
- Wiretap
- Wiretapping
- World Health Organization (WHO)
- Wyoming
- Year In Review
- Zoning
- Zoning Conversion
- Zoning Ordinances
- Zoning Regulations
Authors
- Gary A. Abelev
- Alexander Abramenko
- Yaniel Abreu
- Syed S. Ahmad
- Brandon Bell
- Fawaz A. Bham
- Michael J. “Jack” Bisceglia
- Jeremy S. Boczko
- Brian J. Bosworth
- Shannon S. Broome
- Samuel L. Brown
- Tyler P. Brown
- Melinda Brunger
- Jimmy Bui
- M. Brett Burns
- Olivia G. Bushman
- Matthew J. Calvert
- Grant H. Cokeley
- Abigail Contreras
- Eric S. Crusius
- Christopher J. Cunio
- Alexandra B. Cunningham
- Merideth Snow Daly
- Javier De Luna
- Timothy G. Decker
- Andrea DeField
- John J. Delionado
- Stephen P. Demm
- Mayme Donohue
- Nicholas Drews
- Christopher J. Dufek
- Robert T. Dumbacher
- M. Kaylan Dunn
- Chloe Dupre
- Frederick R. Eames
- Maya M. Eckstein
- Rob Edwards
- Tara L. Elgie
- Clare Ellis
- Latosha M. Ellis
- Juan C. Enjamio
- Kelly L. Faglioni
- Ozzie A. Farres
- Geoffrey B. Fehling
- Hannah Flint
- Erin F. Fonté
- Kevin E. Gaunt
- Andrew G. Geyer
- Armin Ghiam
- Neil K. Gilman
- Ryan A. Glasgow
- Tonya M. Gray
- Meredith Gregston
- Elisabeth R. Gunther
- Steven M. Haas
- Kevin Hahm
- Jason W. Harbour
- Jeffrey L. Harvey
- Christopher W. Hasbrouck
- Eileen Henderson
- Gregory G. Hesse
- Kirk A. Hornbeck
- Rachel E. Hudgins
- Mark Ingram
- Jamie Zysk Isani
- Nicole R. Johnson
- Roland M. Juarez
- Suzan Kern
- Jason J. Kim
- Scott H. Kimpel
- Elizabeth King
- Andrew S. Koelz
- Leslie W. Kostyshak
- Perie Reiko Koyama
- Torsten M. Kracht
- Brad Kuntz
- Kurt G. Larkin
- Tyler S. Laughinghouse
- Gerard T. “Gerry” Leone, Jr.
- Matthew Z. Leopold
- Michael S. Levine
- Ashley Lewis
- Abigail M. Lyle
- Maeve Malik
- Eric R. Markus
- Brandon Marvisi
- John Gary Maynard, III
- Aubrianna L. Mierow
- Gray Moeller
- Reilly C. Moore
- Michael D. Morfey
- Ann Marie Mortimer
- Michael J. Mueller
- J. Drei Munar
- Marcus E. Nelson
- Matthew Nigriny
- Justin F. Paget
- Christopher M. Pardo
- Randall S. Parks
- Katherine C. Pickens
- Gregory L. Porter
- Robert T. Quackenboss
- D. Andrew Quigley
- Michael Reed
- Shawn Patrick Regan
- Jonathan D. Reichman
- Kelli Regan Rice
- Patrick L. Robson
- Amber M. Rogers
- Natalia San Juan
- Katherine P. Sandberg
- Arthur E. Schmalz
- Daniel G. Shanley
- Madison W. Sherrill
- Kevin V. Small
- J.R. Smith
- Bennett Sooy
- Daniel Stefany
- Hak Stepanyan
- Katherine Tanzola
- Javaneh S. Tarter
- Jessica N. Vara
- Emily Burkhardt Vicente
- Mark R. Vowell
- Gregory R. Wall
- Thomas R. Waskom
- Malcolm C. Weiss
- Holly H. Williamson
- Samuel Wolff
- Steven L. Wood
- Jingyi “Alice” Yao
- Jessica G. Yeshman