Ninth Circuit Spoils Putative Class Action Suit Alleging Consumer Confusion Over Almond Milk
Time 2 Minute Read

In a recent unpublished ruling, the Ninth Circuit affirmed the dismissal of a putative class action lawsuit alleging that Blue Diamond Growers mislabeled its almond beverages by failing to identify products as “imitation milk.” Painter v. Blue Diamond Growers, No. 17-55901 (9th Cir. Dec. 20, 2018).

The plaintiff contended that almond milk resembles and is a (purportedly nutritionally inferior) substitute for dairy milk. The plaintiff sought a ruling that Blue Diamond Growers must cease using the term “milk” on the label of its almond milk products or include a nutritional comparison of almond milk to dairy milk. The district court determined—and the Ninth Circuit agreed—that the Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act preempts state laws that impose labeling requirements that are not identical to those under the Act. The Act only requires that foods include the word “imitation” followed by the name of the food imitated. Since almond milk is not a substitute for dairy milk, the plaintiff failed to allege that the products were mislabeled in violation of federal law.

The Ninth Circuit also affirmed dismissal of the plaintiff’s state consumer protection claims, ruling that the plaintiff did not plausibly allege that a reasonable consumer would be deceived into believing that Blue Diamond Growers’ almond milk products are nutritionally equivalent to dairy milk based upon package labels and advertising. To the contrary, the plaintiff conceded that Blue Diamond Growers accurately labeled and advertised its almond milk products.

You May Also Be Interested In

Time 1 Minute Read

In California, shoppers will no longer be offered plastic bags at the grocery store checkout. Under a new law, effective January 1, 2026, single-use shopping bags are banned from any point of sale. This includes bags made from plastic, paper, or other materials that are not recycled paper or certified reusable bags. However, the ban does not apply to bags used before the point of sale, such as produce bags and overwrap for fresh meat.

Time 1 Minute Read

As recently reported on the Hunton Retail Law Resource blog, Washington State became the first-in-the-nation to pass an almost complete ban on the manufacture and sale of cookware containing lead in March 2024. Starting in January 2026, HB 1551 sets the maximum lead content level for cookware and cookware components at five (5) parts per million (ppm). The law is both broad in scope and stringent in its lead limit, making it important for entities that sell cookware or offer cookware for sale in the state of Washington to begin thinking about compliance now. 

Time 3 Minute Read

In March 2024, Washington State became the first-in-the-nation to pass an almost complete ban on the manufacture and sale of cookware containing lead. Starting in January 2026, HB 1551 sets the maximum lead content level for cookware and cookware components at five (5) parts per million (ppm). The law is both broad in scope and stringent in its lead limit, making it important for entities that sell cookware or offer cookware for sale in the state of Washington to begin thinking about compliance now.

Time 1 Minute Read

The FTC has announced the next step in its ongoing review of the “Green Guides.” According to the FTC’s most recent announcement, it is zeroing-in on “recyclable” claims and will be hosting a workshop titled “Talking Trash at the FTC: Recyclable Claims and the Green Guides.” During the workshop, panelists will discuss the kinds of recyclable claims that consumers see in the marketplace, how they perceive or interpret those claims, and the current state of recycling in the U.S.  The half-day workshop is scheduled for May 23, 2023 and is open to the public.

Search

Subscribe Arrow

Recent Posts

Categories

Tags

Authors

Archives

Jump to Page